1983 Christine Lawler
1984 Shawna Pemberton
1985 Maria Ingles
1986 Michelle Chiasson
1987 Kristin Mastroianni – National Semi-Finalist
1988 Alicia Gawrys
1989 Molly Rihm
1990 Nina Cammarata – National Semi-Finalist
1991 Erinn Bartlett – National Semi-Finalist
1992 Victoria Grinder
1993 January Newcombe
1994 Michelle Neves
1995 Erika Ewald
1996 Maria Menounos
1997 Jessica Gregory – National Semi-Finalist
1998 Susie Castillo – Fashion Style Award
1999 Jill Donahue
2000 Monique Jones
2001 Marianna Zaslavsky – Second Runner-up, Miss Teen USA
2002 Amanda Birdsell
2003 Jacquelyn Bruno – Third Runner-up, Miss Teen USA
2004 Allison Bodwell
2005 Alison Cronin
2006 Caroline Faith Caruso
2007 Katie McNiff
2008 Caroline Lunny